The Fear of Easter
I am familiar with the joy of Easter, the warmth of Easter, and the hope of Easter. But the word that struck me in today’s gospel is “fearful.” What is going on here? Why the fear?
Peter gives us some insight in the first reading, telling his listeners that “you killed [Jesus], using lawless men to crucify him.” This reminds us that Jesus’ resurrection is not simply a generic overcoming of death; it is also the vindication of a “man commended to you by God” who was unjustly rejected, tortured and executed. In other words, the resurrection is an act of justice, which means there is also responsibility – and guilt – for his death. There is fear in this.
Likewise, today’s gospel demonstrates the profoundly unsettling character of the resurrection – it did not fit the script, as it were. The women came to anoint a body, not to find evidence of eternal life. Already blown away by a vision of angels, the guards now have more existential fears – namely the punishment they will face when word gets out that Jesus is missing. For their part, the chief priests fear the destabilizing impact of the gospel proclamation, “Jesus is Risen.” The Empty Tomb is startling; it breaks our conventions and flips our expectations.
In our oldest existing copies of the Gospel of Mark, the gospel ends with the word “afraid” (Mk 16:8). Matthew nuances this a bit, combining fear with joy. Yet even “joy” often emerges from a context of pain and suffering, as Pope Francis reminds us in Evangelii Gaudium: “I understand the grief of people who have to endure great suffering, yet slowly but surely we all have to let the joy of faith slowly revive as a quiet yet firm trust, even amid the greatest distress” (EG 6).
As the Pope implies, the Risen Jesus ultimately does not leave us in our fears but calls us through them. Raising the women up from his feet, Jesus commissions them: “Do not be afraid. Go tell my brothers to go to Galilee, and there they will see me.” In the lingering darkness of the night – with its characteristic betrayals, violence, lies, and hypocrisies– a light shines forth on Easter morning.
Life wins. Jesus wins. God wins. On this Easter Monday, go and witness to the surprise of the gospel in your own Galilee.
“This is the day the Lord has made. Let us rejoice and be glad in it!”
Jay Carney
I am an Associate Professor of Theology who came to Creighton in 2011. My research and teaching engage Church History and World Christianity, especially modern Africa.
I am married with four children. My wife Becky is a remarkable woman, and our children have given both of us much love and laughter. I grew up in the Washington, DC area and have also lived in Wisconsin and North Carolina among other places. Prior to coming to Creighton, I worked in campus ministry at the University of Arkansas. In my spare time, I enjoy running, cycling, playing soccer, and listening to music of all types.
After years as a reader of Magnificat and then Give Us This Day, I am now seeing the other side! These reflections entail a very different style of writing than academic journal articles, and I’ve also gained newfound respect for the homilist’s task! I feel that I am “preaching” to myself as much as anyone else. It’s wonderful to know that so many people are walking together as disciples of Jesus Christ. Thank you for your prayers!
